[学科发展]电阻点焊质量监控技术研究进展与分析

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 从点焊过程信号监测、在线评价和实时控制三个方面对近六十年来电阻点焊质量监控技术的研究进展进行了分类综述，综合分析和评价了各类技术的优缺点、应用现状以及发展趋势，旨在为进一步突破电阻点焊质量监控技术瓶颈、促进薄板结构产品制造业的转型升级提供借鉴。

关键词: 电阻点焊, 焊接质量, 过程监测, 在线评价, 实时控制

Abstract: The research progresses of the RSW quality monitoring technologies in the past 60 years were summarized from three aspects: process signal monitoring, online quality assessment and real-time process control. The advantages, disadvantages, application status and development trend of the technologies were analyzed and evaluated comprehensively, aiming at providing useful references to achieve a further breakthrough and promote the transformation and upgrading of thin-walled structure product manufacturing industry.

Key words: resistance spot welding（RSW）, weld quality, process monitoring, online assessment, real-time control

中图分类号:

TG441.7

夏裕俊, 李永兵, 楼铭, 雷海洋. [学科发展]电阻点焊质量监控技术研究进展与分析[J]. 中国机械工程.

XIA Yujun, LI Yongbing, LOU Ming, LEI Haiyang. Recent Advances and Analysis of Quality Monitoring and Control Technologies for RSW[J]. China Mechanical Engineering.

导出引用管理器 EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

链接本文: http://www.cmemo.org.cn/CN/

http://www.cmemo.org.cn/CN/Y2020/V31/I01/100

参考文献

[1]SATONAKA S, MATSUYAMA K I. Review on Inspection Techniques for Spot Welds[J]. Weld in the World, 2000, 44(3):29-36.
[2]王敏. 电阻焊在汽车工业中的应用[J]. 电焊机, 2003, 33(1):1-6.
WANG Min. Application of Resistance Welding in Automotive Industry[J]. Electric Welding Machine, 2003, 33(1):1-6.
[3]韩晓丽, 肖富城, 肖灵. 汽车点焊超声波检测技术发展与趋势[J]. 焊接, 2018(3):34-42.
HAN Xiaoli, XIAO Fucheng, XIAO Ling. Development and Trend of Ultrasonic Testing in Automobile Spot Welding [J]. Electric Welding, 2018(3):34-42.
[4]梁锋, 陈伊娜. 汽车电阻点焊焊接质量的过程控制[J]. 企业科技与发展, 2015(2):44-49.
LIANG Feng, CHEN Yina. Process Control of Automobile Resistance Spot Welding Quality[J]. Enterprise Science and Technology & Development, 2015(2):44-49.
[5]WILLIAMS N T , PARKER J D . Review of Resistance Spot Welding of Steel Sheets Part 1 Modelling and Control of Weld Nugget Formation[J]. International Materials Reviews, 2004, 49(2):45-75.
[6]中国机械工程学会焊接学会电阻焊（Ⅲ）专业委员会. 电阻焊理论与实践[M]. 北京:机械工业出版社, 1994:319-398.
Professional Committee of Resistance Welding(Ⅲ) of Welding Society of China Mechanical Engineering Society. Theory and Practice of Resistance Welding[M]. Beijing:Machinery Industry Press, 1994:319-398.
[7]ROBERTS W L. Resistance Variations during Spot Welding[J]. Welding Journal, 1951, 30(11):1004-1019.
[8]DICKINSON D W, FRANKLIN J E, STANYA A. Characterization of Spot Welding Behavior by Dynamic Electrical Parameter Monitoring[J]. Welding Journal, 1980, 59(6):170s-176s.
[9]HAO M, OSMAN K A, BOOMER D R, et al. Developments in Characterization of Resistance Spot Welding of Aluminum[J]. Welding Journal, 1996, 75(1):S1-S8.
[10]WEI L. Monitoring and Diagnosis of Resistance Spot Welding Process[D]. Ann Arbor:University of Michigan, 1999:22-46.
[11]SAVAGE W F, NIPPES E F, WASSELL F A. Dynamic Contact Resistance of Series Spot Welds[J]. Welding Journal, 1978, 57(2):43s-50s.
[12]NEEDHAM C. Measurement of True Resistance at High Alternating Current[R]. Cambridge:The Welding Institute, 1983:1-6.
[13]GONG L, XI Y, LIU C L. Embedded Artificial Neuval Network-based Real-time Half-wave Dynamic Resistance Estimation during the AC Resistance Spot Welding Process[J]. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2013(12):862076.
[14]GARZA F J, DAS M. Identification of Time-varying Resistance during Welding[C]∥Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference, Proceedings of IEEE. Baltimore, 2000:1534-1539.
[15]GARZA F J, DAS M. On Real Time Monitoring and Control of Resistance Spot Welds Using Dynamic Resistance Signatures[C]∥Midwest Symposium on Circuits and Systems, Proceedings of the IEEE. Lansing, 2001:41-44.
[16]LING S F, WAN L X, WONG Y R, et al. Input Electrical Impedance as Quality Monitoring Signature for Characterizing Resistance Spot Welding[J]. NDT & E International, 2010, 43(3):200-205.
[17]WONG Y R, PANG X. A New Characterization Approach of Weld Nugget Growth by Real-time Input Electrical Impedance[J]. Engineering, 2014(6):516-525.
[18]WANG L , HOU Y , ZHANG H , et al. A New Measurement Method for the Dynamic Resistance Signal during the Resistance Spot Welding Process[J]. Measurement Science and Technology, 2016, 27(9):095009.
[19]夏裕俊. 汽车车身中频电阻点焊过程稳定性在线评价[D]. 哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学, 2016:34-37.
XIA Yujun. On-line Stability Evaluation of Middle Frequency Resistance Spot Welding in Automotive Body Manufacturing[D]. Harbin:Harbin Institute of Technology, 2016:34-37.
[20]WALLER D N. Head Movement as a Means of Resistance Welding Quality Control[J]. British Welding Journal, 1964, 11(3):118-122.
[21]WALLER D N, KNOWLSON P M. Electrode Separation Applied to Quality Control in Resistance Welding[J]. Welding Journal, 1965, 44(4):s168-s175.
[22]TSAI C L, DAI W L, DICKINSON D W. Analysis and Development of a Real-time Control Methodology in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Welding Journal, 1991, 70(12):S339-S351.
[23]JI C T, ZHOU Y. Dynamic Electrode Force and Displacement in Resistance Spot Welding of Aluminum[J]. Journal of Manufacturing Science & Engineering, 2004, 126(3):605-610.
[24]ZHANG H Y, HU J S. Resistance Welding:Fundamentals and Applications[M]. London:CRC Press, 2011:152-169, 181-187.
[25]WU K C. Electrode Indentation Criterion for Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Welding Journal, 1968, 47(10):472-478.
[26]HAEFNER K, CAREY B, BERNSTEIN B, et al. Real Time Adaptive Spot Welding Control[J]. Journal of Dynamic Systems Measurement & Control, 1991, 113(1):104-112.
[27]JOU M. Real Time Monitoring Weld Quality of Resistance Spot Welding for the Fabrication of Sheet Metal Assemblies[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2003, 132(1):102-113.
[28]CHO K S, Chun D W. A Microprocessor-based Electrode Movement Controller for Spot Weld Quality Assurance[J]. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 1985(3):234-238.
[29]CHEN J Z, FARSON D F. Electrode Displacement Measurement Dynamics in Monitoring of Small Scale Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Measurement Science and Technology, 2004, 15(12):2419-2426.
[30]CHANG H S, KWON H C. In-process Monitoring of Micro Resistance Spot Weld Quality Using Accelerometer[J]. Korea Journal of Welding and Joining, 2011, 29(1):115-122.
[31]WANG X F, LI Y B, MENG G X. Monitoring of Resistance Spot Weld Quality Using Electrode Vibration Signals[J]. Measurement Science and Technology, 2011, 22(4):045705-12.
[32]ZHANG Y S, ZHANG X Y, LAI X M, et al. Online Quality Inspection of Resistance Spot Welded Joint Based on Electrode Indentation Using Servo Gun[J]. Science & Technology of Welding & Joining, 2007, 12(5):449-454.
[33]LAI X M, ZHANG X Y, ZHANG Y S, et al. Weld Quality Inspection Based on Online Measured Indentation from Servo Encoder in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement, 2007, 56(4):1501-1505.
[34]XU J, LI Y B, CHEN G L. Study of Weld Quality Real-time Monitoring System for Auto-body Assembly[C]∥Proceedings of SPIE-The International Society for Optical Engineering. Chongqing, 2005:604120-5.
[35]ZHANG Y S, WANG H, CHEN G L, et al. Monitoring and Intelligent Control of Electrode Wear Based on a Measured Electrode Displacement Curve in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Measurement Science and Technology, 2007, 18(3):867-872.
[36]KUSCER L, POLAJNAR I, DIACI J. A Method for Measuring Displacement and Deformation of Electrodes during Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Measurement Science and Technology, 2011, 22(6):067002.
[37]SIMONCIC S, PODRZAJ P. Image-based Electrode Tip Displacement in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Measurement Science and Technology, 2012, 23(6):065401.
[38]SIMONCIC S, PODRZAJ P. Resistance Spot Weld Strength Estimation Based on Electrode Tip Displacement/Velocity Curve Obtained by Image Processing[J]. Science and Technology of Welding and Joining, 2014, 19(6):468-475.
[39]JOHNSON K I, NEEDHAM J C. New Design of Resistance Spot Welding Machine for Quality-control[J]. Welding Journal, 1972, 51(3):338-351.
[40]TANG H, HOU W, HU S J, et al. Force Characteristics of Resistance Spot Welding of Steels[J]. Welding Journal, 2000, 79(7):175s-180s.
[41]SHEARER T W, PETERS C M, Tincker J D. Method and Apparatus for Control of Resistance Welding:U.S. 3553420[P]. 1971-05-01.
[42]STIEBEL A. Apparatus and Method for Monitoring and Controlling Resistance Spot Welding:U.S. 4419558[P]. 1983-12-06.
[43]CHIEN C S, KANNATEY E. Investigation of Monitoring Systems for Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Welding Journal, 2002, 81(9):195-199.
[44]刘桂梅, 韩靖玉, 韩宝生,等. 电阻点焊动态电极力的测试[J]. 焊接, 2006(3):48-50.
LIU Guimei, HAN Jingyu, HAN Baosheng, et al. Measurement of Dynamic Electrode Force in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Welding, 2006(3):48 -50.
[45]HESS J, KERN T, KRIEGL W, et al. Visualization of the Resistance Spot Welding Process in the Production Line[J]. Welding Journal, 1998, 77(12):495s-502s.
[46]GEDEON S A, SORENSEN C D, ULRICH K T, et al. Measurement of Dynamic Electrical and Mechanical Properties of Resistance Spot Welds[J]. Welding Journal, 1987, 66(12):378-385.
[47]翁福娟, 张勇, 叶武, 等. 电阻点焊应变式压力传感器弹性体的设计及应用[J]. 电焊机, 2017, 47(9):9-13.
WENG Fujuan, ZHANG Yong, YE Wu, et al. Design and Application of the Elastomer of Resistance Spot Welding Strain Type Pressure Sensor[J]. Electric Welding Machine, 2017, 47(9):9-13.
[48]王锋, 宋永伦, 张军, 等. MEMS压力传感器在电阻点焊压力测试中的应用[J]. 焊接, 2008(2):38-40.
WANG Feng, SONG Yonglun, ZHANG Jun, et al. Application of MEMS Sensor in Force Measurement in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Welding, 2008(2):38-40.
[49]SWAGGERTY G, SEEL V. System and Method for Monitoring Electrodes of a Welder:U.S. 6084195[P]. 2000-07-04.
[50]张旭强, 陈关龙, 张延松,等. 电阻点焊的伺服焊枪技术特性分析[J]. 焊接学报, 2005, 26(6):60-64.
ZHANG Xuqiang, CHEN Guanlong, ZHANG Yansong, et al. Character Analysis of Servo Gun Technology in Resistance Spot Welding Process[J]. Transactions of the China Welding Institution, 2005, 26(6):60-64.
[51]闵赛金. 阻焊过程中力的测量[J]. 汽车制造业, 2007(12):67-69.
MIN Saijin. Force Measurement in Resistance Welding[J]. Automobile Industry, 2017(12):67-69.
[52]American Society for Testing and Materials. ASTM E751M-12 Standard Practices for Acoustic Emission Monitoring during Resistance Spot Welding[S]. Pennsylvania:American Society for Testing and Materials， 2012.
[53]SCHWENK E B , SHEARER G D . Measuring Projection Weld Strength by Acoustic Emission[J]. Non-destructive Testing, 1973, 6(1):29-33.
[54]六二一所焊接声发射监控题目组. LY12铝合金点焊裂纹的声发射特性探讨[J]. 材料工程, 1979(2):26-30.
621 Institute Welding Acoustic Emission Monitoring Topic Group. Study on Characteristics of Acoustic Emission in Resistance Spot Welding of LY12 Aluminum Alloy[J]. Material Engineering, 1979(2):26-30.
[55]SHAPOVALOV E V, GALAGAN R M, KLISHCHAR F S. Development of a Procedure for the Acoustic-emission Checking of Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Materials Science, 2014, 49(4):532-537.
[56]PODRZAJ P, POLAJNAR I , DIACI J , et al. Estimating the Strength of Resistance Spot Welds Based on Sonic Emission[J]. Science & Technology of Welding & Joining, 2005, 10(4):399-405.
[57]KLYOSUMPHAN T , PRATEEPASEN A . Monitoring Nugget Formation of Nickel-alloys in Micro Spot Welding Using Acoustic Emission[J]. Key Engineering Materials, 2004, 270/273:510-517.
[58]罗震, 胡绳荪, 单平, 等. 用时频分析法研究铝合金电阻点焊过程中的声音信号[J]. 焊接学报, 2004, 25(1):36-39.
LUO Zhen, HU Shensun, SHAN Ping, et al. Application of Time-frequency Analysis to Air-borne Acoustic Signals of Aluminum Alloys Spot Welding[J]. Transactions of the China Welding Institution, 2004, 25(1):36-39.
[59]步贤政, 单平, 罗震, 等. 基于独立分量分析的点焊特征声音信号提取[J]. 焊接学报, 2009, 30(2):41-44.
BU Xianzheng, SHAN Ping, LUO Zhen, et al. Characteristic Extraction of Acoustic Signals Emitted from Resistance Spot Welding Process Based on Independent Component Analysis[J]. Transactions of the China Welding Institution, 2009, 30(2):41-44.
[60]HOUSSAM M. Monitoring and Evaluating the Quality of Nugget Nucleation during Resistance Spot Welding Process by Acoustic Emission Method[D]. Brno:Brno University of Technology, 2018:14-15.
[61]POLAJNAR I, ESMAIL E A. Sources of Acoustic Emission in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 1999, 45(4):147-153.
[62]American National Standard Institute. ANSI/AWS D8.9M-2012 Recommended Practices for Test Methods for Evaluating the Resistance Spot Welding Behavior of Automotive Sheet Steel Materials[S]. Miami:American Welding Society, 2012.
[63]CHO Y, KIM Y, RHEE S, et al. Development of a Quality Estimation Model Using Multivariate Analysis during Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part B:Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 2001, 215(11):1529-1538.
[64]ZHANG H J, WANG F J, XI T, et al. A Novel Quality Evaluation Method for Resistance Spot Welding Based on the Electrode Displacement Signal and the Chernoff Faces Technique[J]. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2015, 62:431-443.
[65]ZHAO D W, WANG Y X, LIANG D J. Correlating Variations in the Dynamic Power Signature to Nugget Diameter in Resistance Spot Welding Using Kriging Model[J]. Measurement, 2019, 135:6-12.
[66]VORONKO V Y , KUTSENKO V I , PODVOISKII Y A . Acoustic Emission Inspection of the Strength of Joints Made by Resistance Welding[J]. Strength of Materials, 1985, 17(7):1021-1028.
[67]HAO M, OSMAN K A, BOOMER D R, et al. Developments in Characterization of Resistance Spot Welding of Aluminum[J]. Welding Journal, 1996, 75(1):S1-S8.
[68]YU J Y. Quality Estimation of Resistance Spot Weld Based on Logistic Regression Analysis of Welding Power Signal[J]. International Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufacturing, 2015, 16(13):2655-2663.
[69]LUO Y , LI J L , WU W. Nugget Quality Prediction of Resistance Spot Welding on Aluminum Alloy Based on Structureborne Acoustic Emission Signals[J]. Science and Technology of Welding and Joining, 2013, 18(4):301-306.
[70]MARTINO, PEREDA M, SANTOS J, et al. Assessment of Resistance Spot Welding Quality Based on Ultrasonic Testing and Tree-based Techniques[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2014, 214(11):2478-2487.
[71]XING B, XIAO Y, QIN Q H , et al. Quality Assessment of Resistance Spot Welding Process Based on Dynamic Resistance Signal and Random Forest Based[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2017,94(1/4):327-329.
[72]PAN Cunhai, DU Sumei, SONG Yonglun, et. al. Multiple Information Fusion and Quality Classification of Aluminum Alloy Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2007, 43(8):181-185.
[73]杨乃文, 张鹏贤, 董亚娅,等. 基于电极位移信号的点焊过程故障诊断[J]. 电焊机, 2008, 38(12):66-69.
YANG Naiwen, ZHANG Pengxian, DONG Yaya, et al. Fault Diagnosis in Process Singing of Resistance Spot Welding Based on Electrode Displacement Signals[J]. Electric Welding Machine, 2008, 38(12):66-69.
[74]GONG L, LIU C L, LI Y M. Control Criteria Determination and Quality Inference for Resistance Spot Welding through Monitoring the Electrode Displacement Using Bayesian Belief Networks[J]. Journal of Advanced Mechanical Design Systems & Manufacturing, 2012, 6(4):432-444.
[75]JAVED M A, SANDERS S A C. Neural Networks Based Learning and Adaptive Control for Manufacturing Systems[C]∥International Workshop on Intelligent Robots and Systems, Proceedings IROS. Osaka, 1991:242-246.
[76]OSMAN K A, HIGGINSON A M, KELLY H R, et al. Monitoring of Resistance Spot Welding Using Multi-layer Perceptrons[J]. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 1994(12):67-73.
[77]DILTHEY U, DICKERSBACH J, DICKERSBACH J. Application of Neural Networks for Quality Evaluation of Resistance Spot Welds[J]. ISIJ International, 1999, 39(10):1061-1066.
[78]LING S F, WAN L X, WONG Y R, et al. Input Electrical Impedance as Quality Monitoring Signature for Characterizing Resistance Spot Welding[J]. NDT & E International, 2010, 43(3):200-205.
[79]张忠典, 李严, 何幸平, 等. 人工神经元网络法估测点焊接头力学性能[J]. 焊接学报, 1997, 18(1):1-5.
ZHANG Zhongdian, LI Yan, HE Xingping, et al. Artificial Neural Network Estimating of Spot Welding Mechanical Property[J]. Transactions of the China Welding Institution, 1997, 18(1):1-5.
[80]张忠典, 李冬青, 赵洪运, 等. 建立点焊质量神经网络监测模型时作用函数的选取[J]. 焊接学报, 2002, 23(3):49-62.
ZHANG Zhongdian, LI Dongqing, ZHAO Hongyun, et al. Selection of Action Function When Establishing the Neural Network Monitoring Model on Quality of Spot Welding[J]. Transactions of the China Welding Institution, 2002, 23(3):49-62.
[81]LEE S R, CHOO Y J, LEE T Y, et al. A Quality Assurance Technique for Resistance Spot Welding Using a Neuro-fuzzy Algorithm[J]. Journal of Manufacturing Systems, 2001, 20(5):320-328.
[82]LIN Z Q, ZHANG Y S, CHEN G L, et al. Study on Real-time Measurement of Nugget Diameter for Resistance Spot Welding Using a Neuro-fuzzy Algorithm[C]∥Proceedings of IEEE， Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference. Como, 2004:2230-2233.
[83]WANG Y X, LIN Z, et al. An Effective Quality Assessment Method for Small Scale Resistance Spot Welding Based on Process Parameters[J]. NDT & E International, 2013, 55(3):36-41.
[84]ZHANG H, HOU Y, ZHANG J, et al. A New Method for Nondestructive Quality Evaluation of the Resistance Spot Welding Based on the Radar Chart Method and the Decision Tree Classifier[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2014, 78(5/8):841-851.
[85]ZHANG H , HOU Y , ZHAO J , et al. Automatic Welding Quality Classification for the Spot Welding Based on the Hopfield Associative Memory Neural Network and Chernoff Face Description of the Electrode Displacement Signal Features[J]. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2017, 85:1035-1043.
[86]ZHANG H J, HOU Y. Quality Estimation of the Resistance Spot Welding Based on Genetic K-Means Cluster Analysis[C]∥IEEE International Conference on Control, Automation and Systems Engineering(CASE). Singapore, 2011:1-4.
[87]ZHANG H J, WANG F J, GAO W G, et al. Quality Assessment for Resistance Spot Welding Based on Binary Image of Electrode Displacement Signal and Probabilistic Neural Network[J]. Science & Technology of Welding & Joining, 2014, 19(3):242-249.
[88]WAN X , WANG Y , ZHAO D. Quality Evaluation in Small-scale Resistance Spot Welding by Electrode Voltage Recognition[J]. Science and Technology of Welding and Joining, 2016, 21(5):358-365.
[89]ZHOU K, YAO P. Overview of Recent Advances of Process Analysis and Quality Control in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2019, 124:170-198.
[90]刘东阳, 张正林, 徐洋, 等. 博世UIR技术在汽车高强钢电阻点焊上的应用[J]. 电焊机, 2017, 47(3):109-112.
LIU Dongyang, ZHANG Zhenglin, XU Yang, et al. Application of Bosch UIR Technology in Resistance Spot Welding of High Strength Steel[J]. Electric Welding Machine, 2017, 47(3):109-112.
[91]ZHOU K , CAI L L. On the Development of Nugget Growth Model for Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Journal of Applied Physics, 2014, 115(16):164901.
[92]SUTTER J E. In-process Ultrasonic Resistance Weld Inspection[C]∥AWS Sheet Metal Welding Conference. Detroit, 2004:11-14.
[93]CHERTOV A M , MAEV R G . A One-dimensional Numerical Model of Acoustic Wave Propagation in a Multilayered Structure of a Resistance Spot Weld[J]. IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control, 2005, 52(10):1783-1790.
[94]FUKUMOTO S, SOEDA A, YOKOYAMA Y, et al. Estimation of Current Path Area during Small Scale Resistance Spot Welding of Bulk Metallic Glass to Stainless Steel[J]. Science & Technology of Welding & Joining, 2013, 18(2):135-142.
[95]NAKATA S , NISHIMURA A , OTANI T, et al. Real-time Measurement of Current Path Area of Spot Welds by Resistance between Electrode Tips[J]. Journal of the Japan Welding Society, 1984, 2:55-61.
[96]BURBANK G E, TAYLOR W D. Ultrasonic In-process Inspection of Resistance Spot Welds[J]. Welding Journal, 1965, 44(5):193s.
[97]KARLOFF A C , CHERTOV A M , MAEV R G. Real-time Ultrasonic Expulsion Detection and Indentation Measurement in Resistance Spot Welds[C]∥Review of Progress in Quantitative Nondestructive Evaluation, American Institute of Physics. Maryland, 2010:1609-1614.
[98]KARLOFF A C, CHERTOV A M, MAEV R G. Enhancing Real-time Ultrasound Signatures of Molten Nugget Growth for Quality Evaluation of Resistance Spot Welds[C]∥IEEE International Conference on Ultrasonic Symposium Proceedings. San Diego, 2009:1533-1536.
[99]LUI A, KARLOFF A C, MAEV R G . M-scan Cross-sectional Imaging of Resistance Spot Welds during Welding[C]∥IEEE International Ultrasonics Symposium Proceedings. Dresden, 2012:2392-2395.
[100]REGALADO W J P. Ultrasonic Real-time Quality Monitoring of Aluminum Spot Weld Process[D]. Windsor:University of Windsor, 2014:100-102.
[101]AMBROZIAK A , MAEV R G , KORZENIOWSKI M , et al. Real-time Ultrasonic Control of Spot-welded Steel Joints[J]. Welding International, 2011, 25(6):419-423.
[102]BARADARANI A, CHERTOV A M, REGALADO W P, et al. Blind Component Separation for Highly Corrupted Ultrasonic Signals in Real-time Spot Weld Inspection[C]∥IEEE International Ultrasonics Symposium Proceedings.Taipei, 2015:161-164.
[103]LUI A, KARLOFF A C, CHERTOV A M, et al. Application of a Programmable Multi-channel Ultrasonic System for In-line Quality Monitoring of Spot Welds[C]∥IEEE International Ultrasonics Symposium Proceedings. Atlanta, 2011:524-526.
[104]HUA L, WANG B, WANG X, et al. In-Situ Ultrasonic Detection of Resistance Spot Welding Quality Using Embedded Probe[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2018,267:205-214.
[105]BRAZUN D, DIACI J, POLAJNAR I , et al. Using Laser Profilometry to Monitor Electrode Wear during Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Science and Technology of Welding & Joining, 2002, 7(5):294-298.
[106]RUISZ J, JURGEN BIBER, LOIPETSBERGER M . Quality Evaluation in Resistance Spot Welding by Analysing the Weld Fingerprint on Metal Bands by Computer Vision[J]. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2007, 33:952-960.
[107]LAI X M, ZHANG X Y, ZHANG Y S, et al. Weld Quality Inspection Based on Online Measured Indentation from Servo Encoder in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation & Measurement, 2007, 56(4):1501-1505.
[108]ELLER T K , GREVE L , ANDRES M , et al. Plasticity and Fracture Modeling of the Heat-affected Zone in Resistance Spot Welded Tailor Hardened Boron Steel[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2016, 234:309-322.
[109]PODRZAJ P, POLAJNAR I, DIACI J, et al. Overview of Resistance Spot Welding Control[J]. Science and Technology of Welding and Joining, 2008, 13(3):215-224.
[110]吴禄, 黎康保, 赵亚光. 关于应用微处理机检测点焊焊接电流有效值的研究[J]. 焊接学报, 1985, 6(1):31-38.
WU Lu, LI Kangbao, ZHAO Yaguang. Study on the Application of Microprocessor in Detecting the Effective Value of Welding Current for Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Transactions of the China Welding Institution, 1985, 6(1):31-38.
[111]GONG L, LIU C L, ZHA X F. Model-based Real-time Dynamic Power Factor Measurement in AC Resistance Spot Welding with an Embedded ANN[J]. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 2007, 54(3):1442-1448.
[112]ZHOU K, CAI L L. A Nonlinear Current Control Method for Resistance Spot Welding[J]. IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics, 2014, 19(2):559-569.
[113]MIKNO Z, WELCEL M, GRZESIK B, et al. Power Loss Distribution in Spot Welding Process at Different Operational Conditions[C]∥International Seminar & Conference on Advances in Resistance Welding. Miami, 2016:1-9.
[114]LEE H, YU J. Development of Fuzzy Controller for Inverter DC Resistance Spot Welding Using System Identification[J]. Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology, 2017, 31(8):3961-3968.
[115]KLOPCIC B, DOLINAR D, STUMBERGER G. Analysis of an Inverter-supplied Multi-winding Transformer with a Full-wave Rectifier at the Output[J]. Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, 2008, 320(20):929-934.
[116]KLOPCIC B, DOLINAR D, STUMBERGER G. Advanced Control of a Resistance Spot Welding System[J]. IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, 2008, 23(1):144-152.
[117]MATSUSHITA M, IKEDA R, OI K. Development of a New Program Control Setting of Welding Current and Electrode Force for Single-side Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Welding in the World, 2015, 59(4):533-543.
[118]WILLIAMS N T, HOLLIDAY R J, PARKER J D. Current Stepping Programmes for Maximising Electrode Campaign Life When Spot Welding Coated Steels[J]. Science & Technology of Welding & Joining, 1998, 3(3):286-294.
[119]KIM J M, WON C Y. Power Control of Resistance Spot Welding System with High Dynamic Performance[C]∥Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society. New Orleans, 1997:845-849.
[120]SHIM Y J, FARIDH M, YU J Y, et al. The Weldability of Dissimilar Three-steel Sheet Using Constant Power Control Method for Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Journal of Material:Design and Applications, 2016, 230(5):959-967.
[121]GONG L , LIU C L , YUAN J , et al. Fuzzy Orthogonal Optimization for Determining the Optimal Resistance Spot Welding Parameters[J]. Applied Mechanics and Materials, 2012, 152/154:1046-1051.
[122]YU J Y. New Methods of Resistance Spot Welding Using Reference Waveforms of Welding Power[J]. International Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufacturing, 2016, 17(10):1313-1321.
[123]PODRZAJ P, POLAJNAR I, DIACI J, et al. Overview of Resistance Spot Welding Control[J]. Science and Technology of Welding and Joining, 2008, 13(3):215-224.
[124]ZHOU K, YAO P, CAI L L. Constant Current vs. Constant Power Control in AC Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2015, 223:299-304.
[125]YU J Y , FARIDH M, PARK Y M. Adaptive Resistance Spot Welding Method That Reduces the Shunting Effect[J]. Journal of Manufacturing Processes, 2018, 35:604-613.
[126]SON J I, IM Y D. Intelligent Controller Implementation for Decreasing Splash in Inverter Spot Welding[J]. 2009, 92(7):1708-1712.
[127]冀殿英, 毕惠琴, 罗贤星, 等. 热膨胀监控微机控制点焊过程的研究[J]. 电焊机, 1986,16(2):7-12.
JI Dianying, BI Huiqin, LUO Xianxing, et al. Study on Microcomputer-controlled Thermal Expansion Monitoring for Resistance Spot Welding Process[J]. Electric Welding Machine, 1986, 16(2):7-12.
[128]SHEARER T W, PETERS C M, TINCKER J D. Method and Apparatus for Control of Resistance Welding:U.S. 3553420[P]. 1971-5-1.
[129]PODRZAJ P, SIMONCIC S. Resistance Spot Welding Control Based on Fuzzy Logic[J]. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2011, 52(9/12):959-967.
[130]ZHANG Y S , CHEN G L . A Neuro-fuzzy Approach to Part Fitup Fault Control during Resistance Spot Welding Using Servo Gun[C]∥The First International Conference on Advances in Natural Computation. Changsha, 2005:1060-1068.
[131]JANOTA M. The Relationship between Thermal Expansion and the Growth of a Resistance Spot Weld[C]∥The Third International Conference on Advances in Welding Processes. Harrogate, 1974:21-26.
[132]WON Y J, CHO H S, LEE C W. A Microprocessor-based Control System for Resistance Spot Welding Process[C]∥American Control Conference, IEEE. San Francisco, 1983:734-738.
[133]CHEN X, ARAKI K. Fuzzy Adaptive Process Control of Resistance Spot Welding with a Current Reference Model[C]∥IEEE International Conference on Intelligent Processing Systems. Beijing, 1997:190-194.
[134]CHO K S, CHUN D W. A Microprocessor-based Electrode Movement Controller for Spot Weld Quality Assurance[J]. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 1985(3):234-238.
[135]CHANG H S , CHO Y J , CHOI S G , et al. A Proportional-integral Controller for Resistance Spot Welding Using Nugget Expansion[J]. Journal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement, and Control, 1989, 111(2):332-336.
[136]MESSLER R W, JOU M, LI C J . An Intelligent Control System for Resistance Spot Welding Using a Neural Network and Fuzzy Logic[C]∥ IEEE Conference on Industry Applications. Orlando, 1995:1757-1763.
[137]姜以宏, 高洪明, 叶广郁. 铝合金点焊热膨胀电极位移法质量实时控制的研究[J]. 焊接, 1995(3):7-11.
JIANG Yihong, GAO Hongming, YE Guangyu. Study on Real-time Quality Control of Thermal Expansion Electrode Displacement for Resistance Spot Welding of Aluminum Alloy[J]. Welding, 1995(3):7-11.
[138]SIMONCIC S , PODRZAJ P. Image-based Electrode Tip Displacement in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Measurement Science and Technology, 2012, 23(6):065401-7.
[139]TANG H , HOU W , HU S J , et al. Influence of Welding Machine Mechanical Characteristics on the Resistance Spot Welding Process and Weld Quality[J]. Welding Journal, 2003, 82(5):116s-124s.
[140]WEI P S , WU T H , CHEN L J . Joint Quality Affected by Electrode Contact Condition during Resistance Spot Welding[J]. IEEE Transactions on Components Packaging & Manufacturing Technology, 2013, 3(12):2164-2173.
[141]MD A, CHOI I D, KIM J W, et al. Effect of Initial (Reference) Welding Current for Adaptive Control and It's Optimization to Secure Proper Weld Properties in Resistance Spot Welding[J]. Journal of Welding and Joining, 2015, 33(6):13-20.
[142]YU J Y. Adaptive Resistance Spot Welding Process that Reduces the Shunting Effect for Automotive High-strength Steels[J]. Metals, 2018, 775(8):1-20.
[143]EL-BANNA M, FILEV D, CHINNAM R B. Intelligent Constant Current Control for Resistance Spot Welding[C]∥IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems. Vancouver, 2006:1570-1577.
[144]ZHOU K , CAI L L. Online Nugget Diameter Control System for Resistance Spot Welding[J]. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2013, 68(9/12):2571-2588.
[145]KAS Z, DAS M. An Electrothermal Model Based Adaptive Control of Resistance Spot Welding Process[J]. Intelligent Control and Automation, 2015(6):134-146.