Fretting Wear Properties of Nuclear TP316H Steels under Different Medium Environments

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-132X.2022.13.006

Abstract

Abstract: Fretting wear tests of TP316H steels under different environments (air/water at room temperature, air/liquid sodium at 450 ℃) were carried out by a self-made fretting wear test rig with the contact configuration of tube-on-rod. After tests, the worn surfaces were examined by a super depth field microscope, 3D optical microscope, SEM(scanning electron microscope) and EDS(energy dispersive spectroscopy) to obtain information on wear morphology, volume and surface chemical compositions. The results show that the highest wear rate of TP316H steels in 450 ℃ liquid sodium and the lowest wear rate is in room temperature water. The wear mechanism of TP316H steels in 4 environments is different. Delamination and oxidative wear are the main wear mechanism in air, and oxidation intensifies with the increase of temperature, while the abrasive wear is dominant in water. The synergistic effect of wear and corrosion is found in liquid sodium at 450 ℃.

Key words: austenitic stainless steel, fretting wear, friction duty, wear mechanism

摘要： 采用自制的液态钠环境微动磨损试验机，研究了核用TP316H传热管在不同环境 (室温大气、室温水、450 ℃大气、450 ℃液态钠)下的微动磨损性能。试验采用管/柱正交接触方式，试验结束后，采用超景深显微镜、三维光学显微镜、SEM和EDS对磨痕形貌、摩擦化学反应及磨损量进行了表征，对比分析了4种介质环境对TP316H的微动磨损的影响，发现TP316H合金管在450 ℃液态钠中的磨损率最大，在室温水中的磨损率最小。4种介质环境下的磨损机理不同，室温大气环境中的磨损主要是剥层和氧化磨损，随着温度升高，氧化磨损加重；室温水环境中的磨损以磨粒磨损为主；高温液态钠环境中的磨损为磨损和腐蚀的耦合协同作用。

关键词: 奥氏体不锈钢, 微动磨损, 摩擦工况, 磨损机理

CLC Number:

TH117

FENG Shuo, CHEN Xudong, TANG Rui, WANG Liwen, ZHANG Fan, CAI Zhenbing. Fretting Wear Properties of Nuclear TP316H Steels under Different Medium Environments[J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(13): 1551-1559,1603.

冯铄, 陈旭东, 汤瑞, 王立闻, 张帆, 蔡振兵. 核用TP316H钢在不同介质环境下的微动磨损性能[J]. 中国机械工程, 2022, 33(13): 1551-1559,1603.

References

［1］周明琢, 张耕培, 卢文龙, 等. 桨毂轴承材料扭动微动磨损行为研究［J］.中国机械工程, 2017, 28(23):2785-2791.
ZHOU Mingzhuo, ZHANG Gengpei, LU Wenlong, et al. Research on Torsional Fretting Wear Behaviors of Material in Hub Bearings［J］. China Mechanical Engineering, 2017, 28(23):2785-2791.
［2］薛向珍，霍启新，郑甲红，等. 基于齿向修形的航空渐开线花键副抗微动磨损研究［J］. 中国机械工程, 2019, 30(20):2447-2455.
XUE Xiangzhen, HUO Qixin, ZHENG Jiahong, et al. Investigation on Improving Fretting Wears of Aeroengine Involute Spline Couplings Based on Tooth Profile Modification［J］. China Mechanical Engineering, 2019, 30(20):2447-2455.
［3］秦红玲，郭文涛，徐翔，等. 脂润滑条件下闸门底枢摩擦副磨损失效评价［J］. 中国机械工程, 2019, 30(6):650-657.
QIN Hongling, GUO Wentao, XU Xiang, et al. Evaluation of Wear and Failure of Gate Bottom Pivot Friction Pairs under Grease Lubrication［J］. China Mechanical Engineering, 2019, 30(6):650-657.
［4］张磊，刘武军，解社娟，等. 核电站指套管磨损缺陷的扫频涡流检测及创新型特征提取［J］. 中国机械工程, 2021, 32(1):18-25.
ZHANG Lei, LIU Wujun, XIE Shejuan, et al. Swept-frequency ET and Innovative Feature Extraction of Abrasion Defects for Thimble Tubes in Nuclear Power Plants［J］. China Mechanical Engineering, 2021, 32(1):18-25.
［5］CAI Zhenbing, PENG Jinfang, QIAN Hao, et al. Impact Fretting Wear Behavior of Alloy 690 Tubes in Dry and Deionized Water Conditions［J］. Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2017, 30(4):819-828.
［6］YOUNG B A, GAO Xiaosheng, SRIVATSAN T S, et al. The Response of Alloy 690 Tubing in a Pressurized Water Reactor Environment［J］. Materials and Design, 2007, 28(2):373-379.
［7］JEONG S H, CHO C W, LEE Y Z. Friction and Wear of Inconel 690 for Steam Generator Tube in Elevated Temperature Water under Fretting Condition［J］. Tribology International, 2005, 38(3):283-288.
［8］刘丽艳, 王一鹏, 朱勇,等. 蒸汽发生器U形管湍流抖振及微动磨损研究［J］. 振动与冲击, 2021, 40(8):35-40.
LIU Liyan, WANG Yipeng, ZHU Yong, et al. A Study on Turbulent Buffeting and Fretting Wear of U-tube of a Steam Generator［J］. Journal of Vibration and Shock, 2021, 40(8):35-40.
［9］PARK G S, KIM G G, KIM S J. Sliding Wear Behaviors of Steam Generator Tube Materials in High Temperature Water Environment［J］. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 2006, 352(1/3):80-84.
［10］李杰, 陆永浩. 位移幅值对 Inconel600合金微动磨损性能和机制的影响［J］. 北京科技大学学报, 2014, 36(10):1328-1334.
LI Jie, LU Yonghao. Displacement Amplitude Effects on the Fretting Wear Behavior and Mechanism of Inconel 600 Alloys［J］. Journal of University of Science and Technology Beijing, 2014, 36(10):1328-1334.
［11］LI J, YANG B B, LU Y H, et al. The Degradation Mechanism of Inconel 690TT Induced by Fretting Wear in Air［J］. Tribology International, 2017, 116:147-154.
［12］XIN Long, MA Miao, LU Yonghao, et al. Comparative Study on Fretting Wear Behaviors of Alloy 600MA in Dry Air and Deionized Water Conditions［J］. Wear, 2019, 418/419:167-179.
［13］ZHANG Xiaoyu, LIU Jianhua, CAI Zhenbing, et al. Experimental Study of the Fretting Wear Behavior of Incoloy 800 Alloy at High Temperature［J］. Tribology Transactions, 2017, 67(6):1110-1119.
［14］XIN L, YANG B B, LI J, et al. Wear Damage of Alloy 690TT in Partial and Gross Slip Fretting Regimes at High Temperature［J］. Wear, 2017, 390/391:71-79.
［15］MING Hongliang, LIU Xingchen, ZHANG Zhiming, et al. Effect of Normal Force on the Fretting Wear Behavior of Inconel 690 TT Against 304 Stainless Steel in Simulated Secondary Water of Pressurized Water Reactor［J］. Tribology International, 2018, 126:133-143.
［16］MING Hongliang, LIU Xingchen, LAI Jiang, et al. Fretting Wear Between Alloy 690 and 405 Stainless Steel in High Temperature Pressurized Water with Different Normal Force and Displacement［J］. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 2020, 529:151930.
［17］王琦安, 龙斌, 王西涛, 等. 中国钠冷快堆材料研发体系的研究［J］. 钢铁研究学报, 2014, 26(9):1-6.
WANG Qi′an, LONG Bin, WANG Xitao, et al. Study on Research and Development System of Materials for Sodium Cool Fast Reactor Technology［J］. Journal of Iron and Steel Research, 2014, 26(9):1-6.
［18］燕春光, 李雅平, 王明政. 钠冷快堆堆容器堆内构件用316型不锈钢及其持久断裂性能［J］. 钢铁研究学报, 2018, 30(12):935-942.
YAN Chunguang, LI Yaping, WANG Mingzheng, et al. Type 316 Austenitic Steels for Reactor Vessel and Internals in Sodium Fast Reactor and Their Creep Rupture Properties［J］. Journal of Iron and Steel Research, 2018, 30(12):935-942.
［19］YUN J Y, PARK M C, SHIN G S, et al. Effects of Amplitude and Frequency on the Wear Mode Change of Inconel 690 SG Tube Mated with SUS 409［J］. Wear, 2014, 313(1/2):83-88.
［20］CHEN Xudong, WANG Liwen, YANG Lingyun, et al. Effects of Temperature on the Fretting Wear Behavior of 2.25Cr-1Mo Tubes Against Gr5C12 Rods［J］. Materials, 2020, 13(15):3388.
［21］XIN Long, WANG Z H, LI Jie, et al. Fretting Wear Behavior and Mechanism of Inconel 690 Alloy Related to the Displacement Amplitude［J］. Tribology Transactions, 2017, 60(5):913-922.
［22］LAI Ping, GAO Xiaochuan, TANG Lichen， et al. Effect of Temperature on Fretting Wear Behavior and Mechanism of Alloy 690 in Water［J］. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 2018, 327:51-60.
［23］CHEN Yanjun, WANG Shunhua, HAO Yu, et al. Friction and Wear Behavior of CrN Coating on 316L Stainless Steel in Liquid Sodium at Elevated Temperature［J］. Tribology International, 2020, 143:106079.
［24］XIN Long, HUANG Qian, HAN Yongming, et al. The Damage Mechanism of Alloy 690TT Against Alloy 600 Caused by Fretting Wear in Room Temperature Pure Water［J］. Materials Characterization, 2020, 161:110176.
［25］STOTT F H, WOOD G C. The Influence of Oxides on the Friction and Wear of Alloys［J］. Tribology International, 1978, 11(4):211-218.
［26］KATO H, KOMAI K.Tribofilm Formation and Mild Wear by Tribo-sintering of Nanometer-sized Oxide Particles on Rubbing Steel Surfaces［J］. Wear, 2006, 262(1):36-41.
［27］STOTT F H. High-temperature Sliding Wear of Metals［J］. Tribology International, 2002, 35(8):489-459.
［28］RIVOLLIER M, COUROUAU J L, TABARANT M, et al. Further Insights into the Mechanisms Involved in the Corrosion of 316L(N) Austenitic Steel in Oxygenated Liquid Sodium at 550 ℃［J］. Corrosion Science, 2020, 165:108399.
［29］SUZUKI T, MUTOH I. Effects of Nitrogen on Corrosion of Stainless Steels in a Liquid Sodium Environment［J］. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 1990, 171(2/3):253-261.
［30］RYNIO C, HATTENDORF H, KLOWER J, et al. On the Physical Nature of Tribolayers and Wear Debris after Sliding Wear in a Superalloy/Steel Tribosystem at 25 and 300 ℃［J］. Wear, 2014, 317(1/2):26-38.

[1]	LI Yongfan, SONG Yong, HAO Muming, ZHUANG Suguo, ZHOU Rui, LI Tianzhao, WANG Chenyin, REN Baojie, LI Xiaozu. Experimental Study of Thermal Deformation and Wear Characteristics of Spherically-assembled Mechanical Seals for Turbo Pumps [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(13): 1550-1558.
[2]	LUO Yanyan, WANG Yongpeng , SUN Zihang , LIANG Hong . Ultrasonic Recognition and Performance Degradation Model of Electrical Connector Fretting Wear [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(02): 164-171.
[3]	PENG Xudong, HE Liangjie, JIANG Jinbo, MENG Xiangkai, HU Liguo, GUO Jungang. Study on Tribological Properties of Phenolic Resin Impregnated Graphite/SiC Ceramic Sealing Materials#br# [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2021, 32(11): 1283-1292.
[4]	XUE Xiangzhen1;HUO Qinxin1;ZHENG Jiahong1;CHEN Xi2;QIN Liyun2. Investigation on Improving Fretting Wears of Aeroengine Involute Spline Couplings Based on Tooth Profile Modification [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2019, 30(20): 2447-2455,2479.
[5]	XUE He;LI Kai;WANG Shuai;ZHAO Kuan. Hardness Indentation Size Effect Analysis of 316L Austenitic Stainless Steels during Cold Working [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2019, 30(01): 105-112.
[6]	LUO Yanyan1,2;ZHANG Le3;MENG Fanbin4;HAO Jie5. Contact Performance Degradation Mechanism of Electrical Connectors under Vibration Conditions [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2018, 29(16): 1952-1957.
[7]	ZHOU Mingzhuo1;ZHANG Gengpei2;LU Wenlong1;ZHANG Po1;LIU Xiaojun1;PENG Heping3. Research on Torsional Fretting Wear Behaviors of Material in Hub Bearings [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2017, 28(23): 2785-2791.
[8]	ZHENG Weitong;WANG Sanmin;XIE Xiaoxin;LI Hao. Dissipated Energy Method for Fretting Wear Analysis of Involute Splines [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2017, 28(18): 2171-2176.
[9]	Kong Weihai, Chen Xuedong, Yan Yongchao, Hu Pan. Effects of Strain-strengthening on Microstructure and Mechanics Behavior of 022Cr17Ni12Mo2 Austenitic Stainless Steel [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2016, 27(08): 1117-1122.
[10]	Yu Shurong, Wang Jielu, Li Shuxin, Song Wei. Study on the Initiation and Propagation of Fretting Fatigue Crack on the Ti-6Al-4V Alloy Dovetail Joint [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2015, 26(24): 3386-3390.
[11]	Han Yu, Wang Kesheng, Chen Xiaoping, Zhang Zhu. Experimental Investigation and Safety Analysis on Cold Stretching for Austenitic Stainless Steel Pressure Vessels [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2014, 25(24): 3359-3364.
[12]	HAN Shu-1, 2, CHEN Hua-Dong-1, 2, LIU Quan-Kun-1, JIAN Ling-Yun-1, CHEN Cong-Sheng-1. Study and Application on Mechanical Behavior of Austenitic Stainless Steels Based on Cold Stretching Technology [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2011, 22(21): 2633-2637.
[13]	HU Xiao-Beng-1, YA Jian-Hui-1, ZHANG Hou-An-2. Effects of Nano-ZrO₂ on Friction and Wear Behaviors of MoSi₂ Coating at High Temperature [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2011, 22(12): 1498-1502.
[14]	WANG Sai-Meng, HU Meng-Heng. Research on Fretting Wear of Wind Turbine Slewing Bearings [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2010, 21(20): 2430-2433.
[15]	HU Xiao-Beng, YA Jian-Hui, HUANG Zhi-Chu, ZHANG Hou-An. Research on Friction and Wear Performance of MoSi₂Coating at High Temperature of 1100℃ [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2010, 21(19): 2364-2368.