Progresses and Applications of Counter-roller Spinning Technology for Metal Thin-walled Cylinders

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1004-132X.2023.02.013

Abstract

Abstract: Counter-roller spinning was a key technique for forming large high-strength metal thin-walled cylinders. The latest research progresses of counter-roller spinning technology for metal thin-walled cylinders were summarized from 4 aspects：plastic deformation mechanism， influence and control of forming accuracy， microstructure evolution and defects， and counter-roller spinning equipment. It is pointed out that the difficulty of plastic flow control caused by time-varying nonlinear characteristics is the bottleneck in engineering applicationes of counter-roller spinning technology. The technical difficulties of counter-roller spinning were analyzed， and the development trends were discussed. It is revealed that the multi-source hybrid active power flexible spinning process of counter-rollers is of a reference for solving the precision spinning forming of ultra-high strength and large size metal thin-walled cylinders.

Key words: metal thin-walled cylinder, plastic flow control, active power spinning of counter-roller, applicative prospect

摘要： 对轮旋压是成形大型高强金属薄壁筒体的关键技术。分别从塑变机理、成形精度影响与控制、组织演变与缺陷、对轮旋压设备等四方面概述了金属薄壁筒体对轮旋压技术的最新研究进展，指出时变非线性特点导致塑性流动控制困难是对轮旋压技术工程化应用的瓶颈。剖析了对轮旋压技术难点，分析探讨了其发展趋势，揭示出多源混动的对轮主动强力柔性旋压工艺对超高强金属、大尺寸薄壁筒体精密旋压成形的借鉴意义。

关键词: 金属薄壁筒体, 塑性流动控制, 对轮主动强力旋压, 应用前景

CLC Number:

TG306

ZHANG Lijun, YANG Ning, LI Zhishun, TAO Jishao, XU Jiayi, LI Fan, ZHAO Shengdun, . Progresses and Applications of Counter-roller Spinning Technology for Metal Thin-walled Cylinders[J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(02): 226-237.

张立军, 杨宁, 李志顺, 陶继绍, 徐嘉怡, 李帆, 赵升吨, . 金属薄壁筒体对轮旋压技术进展及应用探析[J]. 中国机械工程, 2023, 34(02): 226-237.

References

［1］MUSIC O， ALLWOOD J M， KAWAI K. A Review of the Mechanics of Metal Spinning［J］. Journal of Materials Processing Technology， 2010， 210（1）：3-23.
［2］张涛. 旋压成形工艺［M］. 北京：化学工业出版社， 2019.
ZHANG Tao. Spinning Forming Process［M］. Beijing：Chemical Industry Press， 2019.
［3］孙于晴. 30CrMnSiA大直径筒形件对轮旋压技术研究［D］. 西安：航天动力技术研究院， 2019.
SUN Yuqing. Research on Counter-roller Spinning Technology of 30CrMnSiA Large Diameter Cylinder［D］. Xian：Aerospace Power Technology Research Institute， 2019.
［4］刘欣，王国庆，李曙光，等. 重型运载火箭关键制造技术发展展望［J］. 航天制造技术， 2013（1）：1-6.
LIU Xin， WANG Guoqing， LI Shuguang， et al. Forecasts on Crucial Manufacturing Technology Development of Heavy Lift Launch Vehicle［J］. Aerospace Manufacturing Technology， 2013（1）：1-6.
［5］中国机械工程学会塑性工程分会. 塑性成形技术路线图［M］. 北京：中国科学技术出版社， 2016.
Plastic Engineering Branch of Chinese Mechanical Engineering Society. Plastic Forming Technology Roadmap［M］. Beijing：China Science and Technology Press， 2016.
［6］WONG C C， DEAN T A， LIN J. A Review of Spinning， Shear Forming and Flow Forming Processes［J］. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture， 2003， 43（14）：1419-1435.
［7］XIA Qinxiang， XIAO Gangfeng， LONG Hui， et al. A Review of Process Advancement of Novel Metal Spinning［J］. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture， 2014， 85：100-121.
［8］李敏政. 制造高强度大型管件的新方法——逆向旋压［J］. 模具技术， 1994（2）：68-71.
LI Minzheng. A New Method for Manufacturing High Strength Pipe Fittings—Reverse Spinning［J］. Mould Technology， 1994（2）：68-71.
［9］赵升吨. 高端锻压制造装备及其智能化［M］. 北京：机械工业出版社， 2019.
ZHAO Shengdun. High-end Forging Manufacturing Equipment and Its Intelligence［M］. Beijing：Mechanical Industry Press， 2019.
［10］肖作义. 对轮旋压工艺［J］. 新技术新工艺， 2000（6）：23-24.
XIAO Zuoyi. Counter-roller Spinning Process［J］. New Technology and New Process， 2000（6）：23-24.
［11］KALPAKJIAN S， RAJAGOPAL S. Spinning of Tubes：a Review［J］. Journal of Applied Metalworking， 1982， 2（3）：211-223.
［12］李增辉，韩冬，张立武，等. 大型薄壁圆筒旋压成形技术介绍［C］∥全国旋压技术交流年会暨旋压学术委员会成立三十周年庆祝大会论文集. 长春， 2011：19-23.
LI Zenghui， HAN Dong， ZHANG Liwu， et al. Introduction of Spinning Forming Technology of Large Thin-wall Cylinder［C］∥Symposium Book of National Spinning Technology Exchange Annual Conference and Spinning Academic Committee 30th Anniversary Celebration Conference. Changchun， 2011：19-23.
［13］曹学文，张立武，杨延涛，等. 对轮旋压技术研究进展［J］. 热加工工艺， 2013， 42（9）：115-117.
CAO Xuewen， ZHANG Liwu， YANG Yantao， et al. Progress of Research on Counter-roller Forming［J］. Hot Working Technology， 2013， 42（9）：115-117.
［14］HUANG Tao， LU Bo， LUO Wei， et al. Study on Counter-roller Spinning Technology of Large Diameter Aluminum Alloy Cylindrical Parts［J］. Journal of Physics：Conference Series， 2021， 2101（1）：1-10.
［15］郭强，牟少正，张岩，等. D406A钢薄壁圆筒旋压成形及热处理对其组织性能的影响［J］. 锻压装备与制造技术， 2015， 50（6）：111-113.
GUO Qiang， MU Shaozheng， ZHANG Yan， et al. Effect of Spinning Forming and Heat Treatment on Microstructure and Properties of D406A Steel Thin-walled Cylinder［J］. China Metalforming Equipment and Manufacturing Technology， 2015， 50（06）：111-113.
［16］肖作义，张涛. 对轮旋压过程的刚塑性有限元分析［J］. 锻压技术， 1999（1）：27-30.
XIAO Zuoyi， ZHANG Tao. Rigid-plastic Finite Element Analysis of Opposite Roller Spinning［J］. Forging Technology， 1999（1）：27-30.
［17］张涛，李文平，李纬民，等. 对轮旋压金属成形的刚塑性有限元分析［J］. 塑性工程学报， 1999， 6（4）：58-61.
ZHANG Tao， LI Wenping， LI Weimin， et al. Rigid-plastic Finite-element Analysis of Metal Deformation in Counter Roller Spinning［J］. Journal of Plasticity Engineering， 1999， 6（4）：58-61.
［18］李文平. 利用有限元法模拟大直径管件对轮旋压过程的研究［J］. 新技术新工艺， 2003（9）：30-31.
LI Wenping. The Research to Simulate the Formation Process of Counter Roller Spinning for Big Diameter Tube with Finite Element Method［J］. New Technology and New Process， 2003（9）：30-31.
［19］XIAO Gangfeng， XIA Qinxiang， CHENG Xiuquan， et al. Research on the Grain Refinement Method of Cylindrical Parts by Power Spinning［J］. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology， 2015， 78（5/8）：971-979.
［20］ZHU Chengcheng， ZHAO Shengdun， ZHANG Qi， et al. An Algorithm of Counter-roller Flow-forming Force［C］∥International Conference on Tube Hydroforming Technology. Xian， 2015：251-258.
［21］ZHANG Dawei， LI Fan， LI Shuaipeng， et al. Finite Element Modeling of Counter-roller Spinning for Large-sized Aluminum Alloy Cylindrical Parts［J］. Frontiers of Mechanical Engineering， 2019， 14（3）：351-357.
［22］GUO Yaming， LI Mingzhe， WANG Dali， et al. Research on the Power Spinning Method of Large High-strength Cylindrical Parts［J］. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology， 2019， 104（1/4）：1005-1016.
［23］王大力，郭亚明，李亦楠，等. 大型薄壁筒形件对轮旋压成形数值模拟及成形精度分析［J］. 锻压技术， 2020， 45（3）：47-55.
WANG Dali， GUO Yaming， LI Yinan， et al. Numerical Simulation and Forming Precision Analysis on Counter-roller Spinning for Large Thin-walled Cylindrical Parts［J］. Forging and Stamping Technology， 2020， 45（3）：47-55.
［24］XIAO Gangfeng， XIA Qinxiang， CHENG Xiuquan， et al. Investigation on Dimensional Accuracy and Mechanical Properties of Cylindrical Parts by Flow Forming［J］. MATEC Web of Conferences， 2015， 21（6）：03007.
［25］席奇豪，樊文欣，吕伟，等. 对轮旋压的正交试验数值模拟［J］. 锻压技术， 2016， 41（8）：154-158.
XI Qihao， FAN Wenxin， LYU Wei， et al. Orthogonal Test of Counter Roller Spinning by Numerical Simulation［J］. Forging and Stamping Technology， 2016， 41（8）：154-158.
［26］孙于晴，韩冬，杨延涛，等. 大直径30CrMnSiA筒形件对轮旋压成形过程的数值模拟［J］. 锻压装备与制造技术， 2018， 53（6）：89-94.
SUN Yuqing， HAN Dong， YANG Yantao， et al. Research on Precision of Spinning Forming of Large Diameter 30CrMnSiA Cylinder［J］. China Metalforming Equipment and Manufacturing Technology， 2018， 53（6）：89-94.
［27］LI Fan， ZHAO Shengdun， ZHU Chengcheng， et al. Influence of Process Parameters on the Forming Results of Large-sized Cylindrical Parts during Counter-roller Spinning［J］. Journal of Advanced Mechanical Design， Systems， and Manufacturing， 2022， 16（1）：JAMDSM0009.
［28］LUO Wei， CHEN Fei， XU Binbin， et al. Study on Compound Spinning Technology of Large Thin-walled Parts with Ring Inner Ribs and Curvilinear Generatrix［J］. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology， 2018， 98（5/8）：1199-1216.
［29］詹梅，李锐，郑泽邦，等. 一种旋轮、旋压组件及旋压工艺：中国， 113134539A［P］. 2021-07-20.
ZHAN Mei， LI Rui， ZHENG Zebang， et al. A Spinning Wheel， Spinning Assembly and Spinning Process：CN， 113134539A［P］. 2021-07-20.
［30］曾超. 对轮旋压制备纳米/超细晶筒形件方法及试验研究［D］. 广州：华南理工大学， 2014.
ZENG Chao. Research on Forming Method and Experiment of Nanocrystalline/Ultra-fine Grain Structure Cylindrical Parts by Counter-roller Spinning［D］. Guangzhou：South China University of Technology， 2014.
［31］YANG Zhongze， XU Wenchen， WU He， et al. Enhancing Hoop Strength of Titanium Alloy Tube by Cross Spinning［J］. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture， 2020， 152：103530.
［32］QEK S S， CHOOI Z H， WU Z， et al. The Inverse Hall-petch Relation in Nanocrystalline Metals：a Discrete Dislocation Dynamics Analysis［J］. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids， 2016， 88：252-266.
［33］XU Y， BALINT D S， DINI D. A Method of Coupling Discrete Dislocation Plasticity to the Crystal Plasticity Finite Element Method［J］. Modelling and Simulation in Materials Science and Engineering， 2016， 24（4）：045007.
［34］YANG Ning， TAO Jishao， FU Shulin， et al. Research on the Deflection of Metal Bar with V-shaped Notch in Low-stress Cropping Process［J］. Theoretical and Applied Fracture Mechanics， 2021， 114：103017.
［35］SHIMA S， KOTERA H， MURAKAMI H. Development of Flexible Spin-forming Method［J］. Journal of the Japan Society for Technology of Plasticity， 1997， 38（440）：814-818.
［36］RADTKE W. Novel Manufacturing Methods for Titanium Tanks and Liners［C］∥42nd AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference & Exhibit. Sacramento， 2006：5269.
［37］HEGELS J. Optimized Manufacturing Methods for Large Light-weight Overwrapped Titanium Satellite Propellant Tanks［C］∥44th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference & Exhibit. Hartford， 2008：4941.
［38］GROENERT H， ECKERT M， VON P H， et al. Machine Tool for the Production of Tubular Components：US， 4766752［P］. 1988-8-30.
［39］GROENERT H， ECKERT M. Method for Automatically Controlling Spinning Rolls：US， 4951490［P］. 1990-8-28.
［40］ESA. Ariane-5［EB/OL］. ［2018-07-23］. http：∥www. esa. int/esapub/achievements/Sc72s6. pdf.
［41］EUROPIPE. Production and Testing of Large-diameter Pipes［EB/OL］. ［2018-07-23］. http：∥www. europipe. com/fileadmin/europipemodern/files/brochures/08_EP_Production-and-Testing. pdf.
［42］KALPAKJIAN S， RAJAGOPAL S. Spinning of Tubes：a Review［J］. Journal of Applied Metalworking， 1982， 2（3）：211-223.
［43］WIDERA O F. Art of Roll Reducing Ring Wall Thickness：CA， 787105（A）［P］. 1968-06-11.
［44］黄涌，夏琴香，程秀全，等. 筒形件强力旋压用对轮旋压装置的研制［J］. 锻压技术， 2013， 38（6）：62-66.
HUANG Yong， XIA Qinxiang， CHENG Xiuquan， et al. Development of Counter Roller Spinning Equipment for Tube Power Spinning［J］. Forging and Stamping Technology， 2013， 38（6）：62-66.
［45］徐文臣，矫健，陈宇，等. 立式四对轮新型旋压机结构设计及优化分析［J］. 锻压技术， 2019， 44（1）：102-112.
XU Wenchen， JIAO Jian， CHEN Yu， et al. Analysis on Design and Optimization of a New Vertical Counter-roller Spinning Machine with Four Pairs of Rollers［J］. Forging and Stamping Technology， 2019， 44（1）：102-112.
［46］LUO Wei， LU Bo， ZHENG Hongwei， et al. A Research of Spinning Machine：Effect of Different Structures of Feed System on the Static and Dynamic Characteristics［J］. Advances in Mechanical Engineering， 2019， 11（2）：1687814019828451.
［47］郑宏伟，孟广伟，李锋，等. 基于最大熵方法分析轮旋压设备旋轮座可靠性［J］. 清华大学学报（自然科学版）， 2021， 61（11）：1289-1294.
ZHENG Hongwei， MENG Guangwei， LI Feng， et al. Reliability Analysis of the Roller Base of a Counter-roller Spinning Machine Based on the Maximum Entropy Method［J］. Journal of Tsinghua University（Science and Technology）， 2021， 61（11）：1289-1294.
［48］张大伟，朱成成，赵升吨. 大型筒形件对轮旋压设备及应用进展［J］. 中国机械工程， 2020， 31（9）：1049-1056.
ZHANG Dawei， ZHU Chengcheng， ZHAO Shengdun. Progresses of Counter-roller Spinning Equipment and Its Applications for Large-scale Tubular Components［J］. China Mechanical Engineering， 2020， 31（9）：1049-1056.
［49］李帆，赵升吨，李帅鹏，等. 大直径立式全电伺服对轮旋压设备设计及有限元分析［J］. 重型机械， 2021（5）：81-86.
LI Fan， ZHAO Shengdun， LI Shuaipeng， et al. Design and Finite Element Analysis of Large-dia-meter Vertical All-electric Counter-roller Spinning Machine［J］. Heavy Machinery， 2021（5）：81-86.
［50］李继贞，刘德贵，王健飞. 强力旋压成形技术在航空领域的新进展［J］. 航空制造技术， 2014（10）：40-44.
LI Jizhen， LIU Degui， WANG Jianfei. New Progress of Power Spinning Technology in Aeronautics［J］. Aeronautical Manufacturing Technology， 2014（10）：40-44.
［51］赵升吨，李帆，朱成成，等. 一种全电伺服立式三对轮主动强力旋压设备：中国， 110479837B［P］. 2020-08-14.
ZHAO Shengdun， LI Fan， ZHU Chengcheng， et al. An All-electric Servo Vertical Three Pairs of Rollers Active Spinning Equipment：CN， 110479837B［P］. 2020-08-14.
［52］詹梅，雷煜东，郑泽邦. 集成计算材料工程在精确塑性成形中的应用现状与发展趋势［J］. 中国机械工程， 2020， 31（22）：2663-2677.
ZHAN Mei， LEI Yudong， ZHENG Zebang. Status and Development Tendency of Integrated Computational Materials Engineering in Precision Plastic Forming［J］. China Mechanical Engineering， 2020， 31（22）：2663-2677.
［53］黄焕军，张博文，吴光强，等. 基于组合代理模型的车身多学科设计优化［J］. 汽车工程， 2016， 38（9）：1107-1113.
HUANG Huanjun， ZHANG Bowen， WU Guang-qiang， et al. Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Vehicle Body Based on Ensemble Surrogates［J］. Automotive Engineering， 2016， 38（9）：1107-1113.
［54］王北平，韩冬，李俊峰，等. 航天产品旋压智能制造技术发展设想［J］. 固体火箭技术， 2021， 44（5）：571-572.
WANG Beiping， HAN Dong， LI Junfeng， et al. Development of Intelligent Spinning Technology for Aerospace Products［J］. Journal of Solid Rocket Technology， 2021， 44（5）：571-572.

[1]	ZHAO Yanjie, ZHANG Shuangjie, MU Zhenkai, WANG Wei, YAN Huajun, MA Shibo, ZHANG Yonghui. Numerical Simulation of Die Wear of Automobile Covering Parts Based on Dynamic Wear Model [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2024, 35(03): 515-523.
[2]	GAO Song, SUN Yingli, LI Qihan, YING Liang, HAO Zhaopeng, ZHANG Bangcheng. Multi-point 3D Hot Stretch-Bending Process of Titanium Alloy Profiles and Their Microstructure Evolution [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(24): 2986-2995,3014.
[3]	HAN Fei, SUN Weilong, ZHANG Ruoqing. Study on the Influences of Bending Methods on Springback in Roll Forming Processes [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(19): 2353-2361.
[4]	LIU Heng, WANG Zhineng, BIN Guangfu, LIN Weiming, LIN Yaochen, MA Yanxiang. Theoretical Wrinkling Modeling and Critical Forming Radius Analysis of Aviation Tube Bending Forming Considering Circumferential Waveform Characteristics [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(16): 1982-1990.
[5]	XING Menglong, DU Fengshan, FU Yutao. Analysis and Experimental Verification of Corner Filling Degree of Rectangular Tube Roll Forming [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(07): 866-874.
[6]	CHEN Zhongbao, HAN Xinghui, ZHUANG Wuhao, HU Yaxiong, CHEN Mingzhang, . Forming Law of Multi-degree-of-freedom Rotary Forging for High-rib Thin-plate Components and Process Planning [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2023, 34(04): 464-474.
[7]	AI Qingbo, ZHANG Jie, CHENG Hui, LYU Youlong, ZUO Liling, HU Lan. Analysis for Roll-bending Forming Quality of Spaceflight Thin-walled Cylindrical Workpieces Based on PointCPP-LSF Method#br# [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 33(08): 977-985.
[8]	LI Qihan, XU Chuanwei, GAO Song, HAN Xiaoheng, ZHAO Qingming, GU Dongwei, MA Fenglei. Clinching Test for High Strength Steel-Aluminum Alloy Dissimilar Material Sheets#br# [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2021, 32(15): 1861-1867.
[9]	HU Jian1;CHEN Zezhong1;LIU Tao2;YANG Jinhua3. Simulation and Tests on Hot Forming Process Optimization for Door Anti-collision Beams [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2021, 32(01): 92-100.
[10]	ZHAN Mei, LEI Yudong, , ZHENG Zebang, . Status and Development Tendency of Integrated Computational Materials Engineering in Precision Plastic Forming [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2020, 31(22): 2663-2677.
[11]	LI Ming, DAI Peipei, CHANG Zhidong, CHEN Jun, . Springback Control and Compensation of Incremental Forming for Sheet Metal Parts with Open Geometric Feature [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2020, 31(22): 2723-2727.
[12]	HUA Lin, WEI Pengfei, HU Zhili, . Green and Intelligent Forming Technology and Its Applications for High Strength Lightweight Materials [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2020, 31(22): 2753-2762,2771.
[13]	YANG Jun1;YANG Yunsong1;LI Wei1;XIAO Yunya2;ZHOU Zhixiong1. Theoretical Analyses and Experimental Studies for Riveting and Assembly Processes of Automotive Hub Bearing Units [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2017, 28(24): 2949-2956.
[14]	BI Jiang, , ZHAO Changcai, DU Bing, CHEN Xiaohua, DONG Guojiang. Research on Bulging Technology of AA6061 Aluminum Alloy Tubes with Square Cross Sections [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2017, 28(12): 1491-1498.
[15]	XUE Kemin, SUN Dazhi, LI Ping, GONG Zitianzong. Hot Stamping Forming Processes and Experiments of 22MnB5 Ultra-high Strength Steels [J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2017, 28(12): 1498-1503,1511.